The Calm Owner Advantage
Last week, I asked a pretty simple question: Would you hire yourself to manage your rental property? The point was not that owners cannot manage their own homes. The point was that owning a rental property and managing that property as an asset are two different things. This week, I want to stay with that idea because one of the things I see owners do all the time is wait too long to make a decision.
Sometimes they wait because they have a good resident and do not want to raise the rent. Sometimes they wait on maintenance because the problem does not seem that bad yet. Sometimes they know a property needs something, but they figure they can get another year out of it. I understand all of that. The problem is that what looks like the cheaper or easier decision today is not always the cheaper decision six months or a year from now.
That is really where the asset-management mindset comes in. In chess, you do not move just because you can. Sometimes the right move is to hold your position. Sometimes it is to push forward. Sometimes you give up a little now because it puts you in a better position later. The key is knowing why you are making the move and what you are trying to protect.
The Monthly Rent Is Not the Whole Return
Rent gets most of the attention because it is the number owners see every month. But when I look at a rental property, I am looking at more than the rent. I want to know how long the property might sit vacant, what condition it is in, what repairs are coming, what kind of resident we have, what turnover is going to cost, and what similar properties are actually renting for.
That matters because the highest rent does not always give you the best return. If we think a house can rent for $2,100, but the market is clearly telling us $2,050, I am not going to sit there forever trying to prove we can get the extra $50. If we lose a month of rent waiting, we might give up $2,000 or more just to make another $600 over the course of the year. That does not make sense to me from an asset-management standpoint.
Vacancy is part of that equation because the expenses connected to the property do not stop simply because the rent does. The U.S. Census Bureau describes rental vacancy as an important measure of housing supply relative to demand. For an individual owner, the lesson is even simpler: an empty property has a cost, and that cost has to be considered when deciding whether holding out for a higher rent is actually improving the return.
The same thing happens on renewals. If we have a good resident who pays on time, takes care of the property, and does not create unnecessary problems, there is value in keeping that resident. I am not somebody who believes you automatically push every renewal to the highest number possible just because you can. At the same time, you cannot ignore the fact that taxes, insurance, labor, materials, maintenance, and replacement costs keep moving. If the rent has not been reviewed in three or four years, what could have been a small adjustment along the way can suddenly become a much larger one.
So the question is not simply, “Can we raise the rent?” The better question is whether the rent still makes sense when you look at the entire property.
Timing Changes the Decision
We are also getting into the time of year where timing starts to matter more. The rental market we see in June and July is not always the same market we see in October or November. Families have already made school decisions. A lot of the summer military moves have happened. The renter pool starts to change, and homes can take longer to move if they are not priced correctly. That does not mean properties stop renting; it means we have to pay closer attention to what the market is actually doing.
An online estimate might say a house is worth $2,300. Another owner might have a similar house listed for $2,300. That still does not tell me enough. I want to know whether that house actually rented, how long it sat on the market, what condition it was in, whether they had to offer anything to get it rented, and whether it is really comparable to our property.
This is why asking rent and market rent are not always the same thing. The Census Bureau’s housing-vacancy research also notes that vacancy rates, housing prices, and rents are ultimately functions of supply and demand. The national Housing Vacancy Survey provides another look at those changing market conditions, but our job locally is to watch what prospective residents are actually doing in the markets where we manage homes.
Sometimes we test a price for a short period and see how the market responds. If we are getting showings, qualified interest, and applications, that tells us something. If the property is sitting and comparable homes are moving, that tells us something too. I would rather react to real market information than sit there defending a number simply because that is what we hoped the property was worth.
Review the Asset, Not Just the Lease
I believe every rental property should be reviewed regularly, even when everything seems fine. That does not mean we raise the rent every year, and it does not mean we renovate something every year either. It means we look at the property and ask whether the decisions we are making still make sense.
Sometimes the right answer is to leave the rent alone because we have a great resident and the numbers still work. Sometimes the market supports an increase. Sometimes there is a repair that we should take care of now because we already know waiting is probably going to make it more expensive later. One decision affects the next one. Rent affects retention, retention affects turnover, and turnover affects vacancy and make-ready costs. Maintenance affects all of it because the condition of the property eventually shows up in what we can charge, who we attract, and how much we have to spend later.
That is why I do not look at a rental property as just a rent check every month. I look at how the whole asset is performing. The goal is not to make the biggest move every time. The goal is to make the move that keeps the property in the strongest position over time. Sometimes that means raising the rent. Sometimes it means holding it. Sometimes it means spending money today because we know it protects us from spending a lot more later.
That is part of The Calm Owner Advantage. We look at the property before there is a problem, make the decision while we still have options, and try not to wait until the market, the resident, or the condition of the property makes the decision for us.
How is your rental property actually performing?
Whether you own one rental property or a growing portfolio, understanding the monthly rent is only part of the picture. Real Property Management Regions looks at pricing, vacancy, maintenance, resident performance, and the long-term position of the asset together.
Start with a Free Rental Analysis
|
Explore Our Property Management Services
Real Property Management Regions
Property management with an asset-management mindset.
This content is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, tax, or investment advice. Readers should consult with licensed professionals regarding their specific circumstances.
We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.
